Machar rejects probe, cites immunity, committee illegitimacy
Dr. Riek Machar seen in the dock on Monday September 22, 2025, | Credit | Courtesy

The suspended First Vice President rejected the legitimacy of the committee investigating the Nasir incident, insisting that he has immunity and that only Ceasefire and Transitional Security Arrangements Monitoring and Verification Mechanism (CTSAMVM) is mandated to probe peace agreement violations.

On the sixth session on Friday, the investigator continued reading the accused persons’ statements before the special court, including that of Dr. Riek Machar, listed as accused number five.

When given the opportunity by the judge to confirm whether the statement read by the investigator was his, Machar told the court that he rejected the committee for two reasons.

“I did not recognize the committee because I had two reasons. One reason, incidents of violation of the peace agreement are always investigated by CTSAMVM. It is an international structure. South Sudanese are also there with their parties. They investigate such incidents like that of Nasir,” Machar said.

He cited one of the examples, the Leer massacre of 2018, where CTSAMVM conducted the investigation and submitted its report to the Reconstituted Joint Evaluation and Monitoring Commission (R-JEMC), which then forwarded it to IGAD.

“Although the report is now two years, the president has not received it. He has not given time to take it. There are other incidents,” he noted.

According to Machar, the Nasir case is being treated differently because the complainant is now the National Security Service, something he said he had not witnessed in previous investigations.

The special court had ruled that the constitution grants immunity only to the president and not to anyone else, including First Vice President Dr. Machar. However, Machar insisted that he has immunity, which he cited as his second reason for rejecting the investigation committee.

“I said I am the first vice president. I have immunity, and then I told them, I will give you a statement, but I don't accept to be investigated by you,” Machar emphasized.

Machar maintained that his written statement to the investigators was long and detailed, but he dismissed the process as flawed.

According to the investigator, Machar’s statement was recorded on April 14, 2025, after he was placed under house arrest on March 26, 2025, on the orders of President Salva Kiir.

Machar and seven others face charges including murder, conspiracy, terrorism, financing of terrorist acts, treason, destruction of public property and military assets, and crimes against humanity, stemming from the March 2025 Nasir clashes between the White Army and the SSPDF, which killed a general and over 250 soldiers.